Water Treatment
If you are in doubt, treat the water. You can die a lot faster
or be sick for a lot longer from drinking a drop of contaminated
water than you can from drinking no water at all. See the table
below for a comparison of the effectiveness of different methods.
Effectiveness of different treatment methods:
Legend:
Effectiveness:
|
Method |
Salts |
Pathogens |
Odour
and taste problems |
Turbidity |
|
Straining |
X
|
X
|
X
|
~ |
|
Aeration |
X
|
X
|
~ |
X
|
|
Storage |
X
|
~ |
~ |
~ |
|
Boiling |
X
|
+ |
X
|
X
|
|
Chlorine |
X
|
+ |
X
|
X
|
|
Solar
Disinfection |
X
|
+ |
X
|
X
|
|
Distillation |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
|
Slow
Sand Filter |
X
|
+ |
+ |
+ |
|
Rapid
Sand Filter |
X
|
X
|
~ |
+ |
For a more detailed comparison, see WELL Technical Brief #48.
Simple Treatments
Straining
Straining turbid (cloudy) water through a clean handkerchief
or other fine, cotton cloth is a good way of straining out larger
particles of suspended contaminants like dirt. It can also remove
certain tiny organisms (like copepods) that may carry pathogens,
though such organisms are not present in all climates. Straining
turbid water will improve the effectiveness of most other treatment
methods, and is a good first step.

Aeration
Aeration adds air to water and reduces the concentration of
“volatile” substances like hydrogen sulfide, which
affect the taste and smell of water. It can also oxidize and immobilize
elements like iron and manganese, which can cause taste and smell
problems with water if present in excess. (They also stain clothes
if the water is used for laundry.)
To aerate water, just shake a partly filled container of water
vigorously, or pour it through a perforated tray containing small,
clean pebbles.
Storage
Just storing untreated surface water will improve its quality.
Particles settle out, and parasites that may be present will die,
usually within a few days, without access to a host. Storing water
for only 24 hours will kill about half of the bacteria in it.
The improvement in quality will be greater at higher temperatures
and over longer periods. If you are leaving turbid (cloudy) water
to settle out, remember to take your water from the top layer,
once the visible particles have settled.
Water containers should always be covered to prevent contamination.
WELL (see water notes) suggests using a three container system.
The first container is used to put new water into, and the water
may be strained as it is poured into this container. After one
day, this water is poured into the second container, being careful
to leave sediment or cloudy layers behind to be discarded. Using
a tube to siphon water to the next container can help to leave
the sediment undisturbed. The next day, water from the second
container is poured into the third. The water in the third container
has sat for at least two days, and is used for drinking water.
WELL suggests occasionally rinsing this container with scalding
water to sterilize it.
Glass containers are good for maintaining water quality, but
are heavy and can break. You can look for food grade plastic containers
for storing water. The preferred types of plastic for food are
“Polyethylene Terephthalate” (PETE) or “High
Density PolyEthylene” (HDPE). Look for the letters “PETE”
or “HDPE” or the recycling numbers “1”
or “2” stamped on the bottoms. However, keep in mind
that some chemicals stored in the containers originally may leach
into the drinking water stored inside. For example, the toxic
aspartame in containers used in diet pop may leach into the drinking
water, so such containers should be avoided if possible. Never
reuse a plastic container that has stored toxic chemicals.
Disinfection
Disinfection kills the pathogens in the water. It is most effective
if the water is relatively free of sediment and organic materials,
so it should be the final stage in water treatment, after other
contaminants have been removed.
Disinfection by Boiling
You can kill the pathogens in water by boiling it. At sea level,
water simply brought to a boil is safe, but add one minute to
the boiling time for every additional thousand metres (3300 feet)
in altitude. (It’s something of a myth that water has to
be boiled for five or ten minutes to be safe—this is just
a waste of fuel. See Miller below, and other sources.) Be sure
to strain out any larger particles by straining through a cloth,
first. If it tastes “flat”, pour it back and forth
between two containers a few times to aerate it. You can also
add a chunk of charcoal from your fire, or some pine needles,
during boiling, and remove them before drinking, to improve taste.
Boiling notes:
Miller, DeWolfe, ‘Boiling drinking-water: A critical look’,
Waterlines, Vol.5, No.1, IT Publications, London, 1986.
Chemical Disinfection
Disinfection by adding chlorine (usually in the form of bleach)
is also an option. However, it isn’t ideal, because the
proper amount of chlorine to use can be difficult to determine,
as well as because of the unpleasant taste and possible health
side effects of ingesting chlorine. However, it is a very effective
disinfectant.
The strength of chlorine compounds varies widely, and depends
on storage conditions. Household bleach will rapidly lose its
strength over time, though powdered chlorine (calcium hypochloride)
will last longer, up to ten years under ideal storage. Use only
pure bleach. Do not use bleach with fabric softener, or other
laundry additives, because they are very likely poisonous.
To disinfect clear water with liquid bleach, first look at the
concentration of chlorine you have in your bleach. For 1%, use
10 drops per litre, for 2-6% try 2 drops per litre, for 7-10%
use 1 drop per litre, and let sit for at least 30 minutes. For
slightly cloudy water, use at least double the number of drops.
There should be a slight chlorine odour after. Otherwise, repeat
the dose and wait another 15 minutes. Let it sit to reduce chlorine
taste and smell.
Aerating chlorinated water after disinfection will also help
the taste, as will adding a pinch of powdered vitamin C, which
will neutralize the chlorine.
You can use household, medical iodine to purify water as well.
For 2% USP strength, add 5 drops to clear water and 10 drops to
cloudy water.
Chemical disinfection notes:
“Be Prepared with a 3-Day Emergency Food Supply,”
by E. Schafer, C. Hans, E. Jones Beavers and D. Nelson, Iowa State
University Cooperative Extension, November, 1997
Solar Disinfection
Solar disinfection works by a combination of exposing the water
to the ultraviolet rays of the sun and raising the temperature,
which kills microorganisms present. This technique is most effective
in areas between approximately 35°N and 35°S, areas which
receive large amounts of solar radiation each year. The American
Southwest is an area in North America which also receives a lot
of solar radiation.
In this method, containers of water are placed in direct sunlight,
for a period of at least six hours. The water must be relatively
clear, and shallow, to allow penetration of UV rays.
Glass containers can be used (but not window glass, which does
not transmit UV radiation very well), but they are heavier, can
break, and take longer to heat up. Plastic bottles made of PETE
(polyethylene teraphtalate) or PVC (polyvinyl chloride) are both
good choices, but PETE is preferable, since it is not likely to
leach harmful additives into the water. Bottles made of PVC often
have a bluish tinge, and when burned, smells strong and unpleasant.
PETE burns more easily, and has a sweetish smell.
Bags of water can also be used, and can be more effective since
they can store water more shallowly.
Aerating the water by shaking it before placing it in the sun
will significantly increase the effectiveness of this method of
disinfection. When bottles become old and scratched, and start
to become opaque, they should be replaced. Newer bottles will
transmit UV light better.
The Swiss development agencies EAWAG and SANDEC recommend leaving
the water out for at least six hours on sunny or partly cloudy
days, or two consecutive days in cloudy weather. This primarily
applies to very sunny regions, so solar disinfection is not a
reliable method in less sunny regions.
Painting bottles black on one side (the side placed down) will
help to heat the water up. If the water reaches a temperature
of more than 50°C (122°F) for at least one hour in the
middle latitudes, it is safe. Placing the bottles on corrugated
metal roofing will keep them in place and help to increase the
temperature.

Using reflectors to concentrate sunlight on the water vessel
will increase the effectiveness of this method by increasing the
amount of UV radiation the water is exposed to, and increasing
the temperature.
Solar disinfection notes:
Swiss development agencies have a large amount of information
about solar disinfection at www.sodis.ch.
Distillation
Distillation works by evaporating water from a suspect source,
which then condenses, leaving distilled water. This is an excellent
way to get drinking water from seawater, and is the only method
described here which will remove salt.
You can make a stove-top still, like the one shown, very easily.
You place the still on top of a pot which is cooking (assuming
that you aren’t using a fuel-saving haybox as discussed
in “Cooking”.)
Solar stills can be made easily and cheaply to provide a quick
source of clean water. They provide enough water for personal
use, but not enough for gardening, since they would have to be
as large as the garden itself to provide enough water. They use
solar radiation to evaporate water from a contaminated or questionable
water source.
To make a solar still, make a small greenhouse out of the materials
you have available. See the Cloche Style still for an example
using windows or plastic. Make a container for the source water
lined with black, so that the water will heat up as much as possible
in the sun. You may want to insulate underneath the source container
if you are going to place the still on the ground. Then place
a shallow trough along the lower edge to capture the condensed
droplets as they slide down the glass.
Plastic sheeting can also be used, but some people report that
droplets usually do not cling to plastic as well as glass, so
they may drop back into the source container. However, the “clinginess”
can be improved by lightly rubbing sandpaper over the interior
surface of the plastic. If you do use plastic, make sure that
it is pulled tight over the frame, or the wind may flap and tear
it.
You can make a solar still with a sloped glass covering like
the one shown below. This same device can be used as a solar food
dehydrator, or a cold frame for gardening. (This is an example
of how you can create equipment appropriate to your bioregion
and climate: for example, if you have rainy springs, hot dry summers,
and moderate autumns, you can use this device to start your vegetables
in the spring, while you are drinking rainwater, and then use
it as a still to provide drinking water in the summer, and then
to dry the produce in the fall.) You can make this kind of still
(dehydrator, coldframe) from 3’ by 6’ patio door windows,
which are regularly replaced at many apartment buildings. You
may be able to buy them cheaply by the hundred. Admittedly, you
might not be able to use them all yourself, but your neighbours
will thank you when you share. (If you store glass in such numbers,
be sure to store the panes with spacers so that they don’t
touch - water trapped between them will etch and mar the glass
permanently.) For discussion on the glass’s best angle see
page 34.

You can also make a lightweight, portable version, like the one
shown below. (Design from the excellent “Survival Scrapbook”
volume three). This design would also work well on a rooftop.

A still can produce about 4 litres of water per square metre
(1.26 litres per square yard), per day, on a good day.
The upside of the solar still is that you can put your wash water
back into the still to get drinking water again. You could even
put urine in.
For stills, keep in mind that the distilled water produced also
has no trace minerals present, so it is not ideal as the sole
drinking water source for young children over extended periods
of time.
Exercise: Build a solar still for you and your
family or housemates. Can you live off of the product for a week?
How much of your water needs can you meet?
Sand Filters
Slow Sand Filters
In slow sand filtration, the source water flows slowly through
a bed of fine sand. To work, the water must be relatively clear,
and the flow relatively constant. The water flows through at a
rate of about 10 to 20 centimetres per hour (4 to 8 inches per
hour). The minimum acceptable depth of sand to function effectively
is 65 centimetres (25.6 inches).
The slow sand filter works because of a biologically active microbial
film that forms on the top layer of the sand, known as the “schmutzdecke”.
The schmutzdecke captures and “eats” organisms in
the water. The schmutzdecke takes about one to two weeks to form,
and so water coming from the filter before that should not be
used for drinking.
To get a quantity of fine, uniform sand, you can try sifting
it through a mosquito net or other fine screen.
The filter should be filled from the bottom up, to prevent the
formation of air bubbles in the sand which would slow the flow
of water.
Eventually the sand filter will need to be cleaned, because the
schmutzdecke will thicken and slow the flow of water excessively.
Fortunately, this thickening will not impair the safety of the
filter. To clean, drain the water to slightly below the top of
the sand, and scrape off the very top layer. Then fill up from
the bottom. It will require another one or two weeks for the schmutzdecke
to regrow.
Rapid Sand Filters
Rapid Sand Filters work to remove particles and turbidity in
water, but do not form a schmutzdecke, and are not effective against
pathogens.
One type of rapid sand filter that you can make is simply a barrel
with a thick layer of sand on top of a perforated metal plate,
on top of a layer of stones, similar to the slow sand filter.
However, the water travels upward instead of downward, and can
travel at a faster rate; about 0.5 to 1.5 metres per hour (20
inches to 60 inches per hour). The sand in this filter is at least
30 cm thick. The rapid sand filter needs to be “backwashed”
(that is, flushed of sediment by letting the water flow in the
opposite direction) regularly, perhaps as often as every day,
depending on the turbidity of the water and the amount of spare
water available for flushing.
Since slow sand filtration requires clear water, and rapid sand
filtration provides clear water, you can put them in a gravity-fed
sequence, as shown. Additionally, since the maintenance downtime
for the slow sand filter is so long, you may wish to have several
slow sand filters running simultaneously, so that you will always
have at least one working.
Sand filter notes:
http://www.refugeecamp.org/learnmore/water/slow_sand_filter.htm
http://www.ce.vt.edu/program_areas/environmental/teach/wtprimer/slowsand/slowsand.html
http://www.esemag.com/0500/sand.html
WELL Technical Brief #59: Household Water Treatment 2
General Water Notes
There are a few methods which I skipped over in this section,
because they didn’t fit into the requirements. Solar pasteurization
is a treatment method which is distantly related to solar disinfection,
but slightly more difficult. Essentially it involves elevating
the temperature of water to more than 65ºC (149ºF) for
more than six minutes, using sunlight (or other sources). The
advantage is that it does not require UV radiation for disinfection
and is more appropriate for non-equatorial latitudes. For more
information, check out:
http://solarcooking.org/docs.htm#Water%20Pasteurization
There are also numerous commercial, small scale means of water
treatment which aren’t appropriate for improvised situations,
which you can find out more information about for yourself. These
include halozone tablets, and other chemical treatment methods,
which you can get at pharmacies or camping / outfitting stores.
There are other general sources for learning more about drinking
water below, which I used writing this section.
The IRC International Water and Sanitation Centre has an extensive
online database of water-related publications: www.irc.nl/ircdoc/
UNHCR Water Manual for Refugee Situations
UNHCR Handbook for Emergencies
These and other UN refugee references are available online at:
www.the-ecentre.net/resources/e_library/index.cfm
WELL Technical briefs, available at: www.lboro.ac.uk/orgs/well/resources/technical-briefs/technical-briefs.htm
Water for the World Technical Notes
www.lifewater.org/wfw/wfwindex.htm has an extensive number of
technical briefs on water and sanitation.
The Drinking Water Book, by Colin Ingram
|